Differences between revisions 2 and 3
Revision 2 as of 2014-02-28 20:04:06
Size: 7159
Comment:
Revision 3 as of 2014-02-28 20:17:04
Size: 7669
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 19: Line 19:
Watching the Chinese leadership in particular shows a steady progression towards the diffusion of power, from the strongman to the meritocracy. While the displacement of the poor for economic projects, and the persecution of the Failun, are disturbing to this American boy, I can see worse in American history, as recently as my parent's times. When China's per capital GDP reaches that of 1940s America, I expect that wealth to be spent on personal freedom. If server sky can bring that economic growth to western China sooner, and build cameraderie between those ethnic minorities and the Han majorities of eastern China, then I don't mind the government tweaking the conversation to maximize the conversion. Watching the Chinese leadership in particular shows a steady progression towards the diffusion of power, from strongmen to meritocracies. Most Americans remember Mao, but how many can name the president of China (2014 answer: Xi Jinping) or his undergraduate degree (Chemical Engineering, Tsinghua University). I may not agree with the ideology, but the leaders of China are chosen for intelligence and administrative skill, something Americans can only dream about. While the displacement of China's poor for economic projects, and the persecution of the Failun, are disturbing to this American boy, I can see worse in American history, as recently as my parent's times. When China's per capital GDP reaches that of 1940s America, I expect that wealth will be spent on personal freedom and on education. If server sky can bring that economic growth to western China sooner, and build cameraderie between those ethnic minorities and the Han majorities of eastern China, then I don't mind the government tweaking the conversation to maximize the conversion. An educated China will capture the essence, if not the particulars, of the American revolution.
Line 21: Line 21:
My job, as a technologist, is to make technological choices that move us toward these desirable goals quickly and as painlessly as possible. If I can make choices that aid education-obsessed bureaucrats at the expense of the power-obsessed kleptocrats, the internal forces contending for mastery inside China will move in the right directions, directions that I as a foreigner cannot make well-informed decisions about. My job, as a technologist, is to make technological choices that move us toward these desirable goals as quickly and painlessly as possible. If I can make choices that aid education-obsessed bureaucrats at the expense of the power-obsessed kleptocrats, the internal forces contending for mastery inside China will move in the right directions, directions that I as a foreigner cannot make well-informed decisions about.
Line 23: Line 23:
There are countries overdue for repair - North Korea seems like one - but I do not understand the historical forces that make a North Korea come about, and until we understand why people would willingly subject themselves to what appear as atrocities to westerners, our meddling could make the situation worse. Understand the machine and the function it performs, in obsessive detail, before you attempt to improve it. The path to improvement is probably surprising, and not obvious to outsiders. Since North Korea is poverty stricken, and lacks the communication infrastructure we take for granted in the west, there is no hardware on the ground to work with space assets anyway, and those possessing clandestine communication tools will be identified and murdered if we send anti-government messages through them. If instead, we censor ourselves, and use those channels to bring wealth and knowledge to the possessors, they will be in a much better position to create peaceful and appropriate changes to North Korea, with the tacit cooperation of the pragmatists among their country's leadership. There are countries most westerners consider overdue for repair, like North Korea. I do not understand the historical forces that make a North Korea come about, even though I've read many books about the country. Until we understand why people would willingly subject themselves to atrocities, our meddling could make the situation worse. Understand the machine and the function it performs, in obsessive detail, before you attempt to improve it. The path to improvement is probably surprising, and not obvious to outsiders like me. Relevant to space sourced communication, North Korea is poverty stricken, and lacks the communication infrastructure we take for granted in the west. There is no hardware on the ground to listent to space assets. Those possessing clandestine communication tools will be identified and murdered if we send anti-government messages through them. If instead, we censor ourselves, and use those channels to bring wealth and knowledge to the possessors, they will be in a much better position to create peaceful and appropriate changes to North Korea, with the tacit cooperation of the pragmatists among their country's leadership.

Censorship

The Outernet group proposes putting hundreds of cubesats in orbit to broadcast internet and bypass censorship. Over time, I hope they learn more about space, technology, history, the International Telecommunications Union, and the psychology that underlies Realpolitik.

If I was Dictator Of The World, I would force everyone to be free, then abolish my office. Sounds silly, right?

The American revolution was unique for its time (and perhaps in history) because the American colonies were the most highly literate population in the world. The colonies absorbed many of the British empire's rabble rousers and religious zealots, and violated copyright by copying without permission a lot of English literature, and did all this far from the control of crown and parliament. The colonies were hotbeds of radical Protestantism, focused on reading and interpreting scripture, which meant most people owned and could read bibles. I may not think the same way, but I can see how that thinking led to a populace biased towards self-government and the concommitant self-control. Yet with all that book learning, Americans were also organized pirates and smugglers and slave traders, scofflaws whose excesses required many small and large wars to tame.

In an age of nuclear and biological weapons and mass propaganda, the world cannot follow America's path to freedom, nor should it emulate the decay of freedom that mass communications can bring about. The world is evolving towards peace and freedom and prosperity, but there are no shortcuts - education comes first, and that can take generations. Without education, or with indoctrination pretending to be education, "free" communication can support genocide as easily as it spreads knowledge. The excesses of Nazi Germany, or the Rwandan and Congo genocides, show what unmanaged communication can do.

While there are horrible kleptocratic perversions of the process, the education of China and India are proceeding admirably, and I hope tools like Server Sky can contribute. One does not need to look far back into history, however, to see how both these countries have been repeatedly scarred by bad communication - the Taiping rebellion of 1846 and the partition of India in 1947 were responsible for millions of deaths. The ignorance and intolerance that led to these atrocities is slowly vanishing from both countries, but it is not gone, and the communication channels of both countries are censored partly to prevent future eruptions of violence. Granted, much of the impetus is to protect those in power, but people in power get old and die. Their educated replacements will include the Gorbachevs and Abdullahs and Lees who will use their control to educate their people towards independence.

It would be great if we could just throw a switch and turn everyone in the world into educated and wealthy cosmopolites. I wouldn't mind throwing a switch and turning the video vegetables of the United States into educated cosmopolites (clue: we aren't). But that is not going to happen - sometimes, the Big Guy with the dozen palaces is correct when he tells us to eat our veggies and not have promiscuous sex with strangers.

So, while I would love to design server sky to destroy censorship, the death toll from my naive American meddling could result in the death of billions - including my own. So careful thought is required, to design the infrastructure to foster education while discouraging demagoguery, to give dictatorial leaders tools that will help them lead their countries towards peace and plurality. Imposing American exceptionalism on the world is a remarkably ignorant undertaking.

The International Telecommunication Union assigns access to orbits and frequencies, and nations with launch capability ( US, Russia, China, etc) are willing members of this productive consensus organization. China and Russia have some enormous tasks ahead, and while they don't do things The American Way, their leaders are not by any means the Stalins and Hitlers and Maos that made the mid twentieth century a genocidal horror. Those leaders and their representatives at the ITU can put the kybosh on any space project, except for those launched by powerful military organizations.

Watching the Chinese leadership in particular shows a steady progression towards the diffusion of power, from strongmen to meritocracies. Most Americans remember Mao, but how many can name the president of China (2014 answer: Xi Jinping) or his undergraduate degree (Chemical Engineering, Tsinghua University). I may not agree with the ideology, but the leaders of China are chosen for intelligence and administrative skill, something Americans can only dream about. While the displacement of China's poor for economic projects, and the persecution of the Failun, are disturbing to this American boy, I can see worse in American history, as recently as my parent's times. When China's per capital GDP reaches that of 1940s America, I expect that wealth will be spent on personal freedom and on education. If server sky can bring that economic growth to western China sooner, and build cameraderie between those ethnic minorities and the Han majorities of eastern China, then I don't mind the government tweaking the conversation to maximize the conversion. An educated China will capture the essence, if not the particulars, of the American revolution.

My job, as a technologist, is to make technological choices that move us toward these desirable goals as quickly and painlessly as possible. If I can make choices that aid education-obsessed bureaucrats at the expense of the power-obsessed kleptocrats, the internal forces contending for mastery inside China will move in the right directions, directions that I as a foreigner cannot make well-informed decisions about.

There are countries most westerners consider overdue for repair, like North Korea. I do not understand the historical forces that make a North Korea come about, even though I've read many books about the country. Until we understand why people would willingly subject themselves to atrocities, our meddling could make the situation worse. Understand the machine and the function it performs, in obsessive detail, before you attempt to improve it. The path to improvement is probably surprising, and not obvious to outsiders like me. Relevant to space sourced communication, North Korea is poverty stricken, and lacks the communication infrastructure we take for granted in the west. There is no hardware on the ground to listent to space assets. Those possessing clandestine communication tools will be identified and murdered if we send anti-government messages through them. If instead, we censor ourselves, and use those channels to bring wealth and knowledge to the possessors, they will be in a much better position to create peaceful and appropriate changes to North Korea, with the tacit cooperation of the pragmatists among their country's leadership.

I would love to hear from people in China and elsewhere, telling me about the tools they need to create a better world. Those seeking violent revolution and the punishment of enemies, or the copying of America elsewhere, should save their breath. I want educated and responsible freedom for individual people, as many as possible as soon as possible, not abstractions like nations per se. That can be achieved through migration and communication, rarely though confrontation and subversion. Be a good friend, and help your friends enough, and few will wish to remain your enemies.

Censorship (last edited 2014-03-01 03:06:14 by KeithLofstrom)